WEEK12 Hackerdom Ideals

 What society defines to be a hacker is a distorted version of its  original definition. While the definitions from inside the hackerdom have a rather social, goodhearted and innovative element, the non-IT society sees hackers as threats to their personal information. In his text “Hacker Ethic” the philosopher Pekka Himanen proposes seven ideals that hackers should abide.

The ideals, although mentioning ethics at several points, do not define a clear limit, which I would expect to exist in a text defining the hackerdom. The ideals; passion and freedom, highlight the creativeness that should drive a hacker, which I agree with. Generally I agree that whatever one does should be pushing oneself, motivating to explore the depth of the field, however if that means violating other legal and ethical codes, that would be too much freedom. The original definition of a hacker, a passionate IT expert, does not imply an unethical use of its skills, however a hacker by the societally known definition, an IT expert that breaks security barriers, is also a passionate IT expert, therefore within the seven ideals there should be a mention of certain ethics. It is however complicated to incorporate ethics that would limit aspects of the digital world, whilst one of the ideals is “freedom”. However, the lack of criminal intent should be phrased within the definition, to avoid misinterpretation.

Another ideal is the (hacker) money ethics. Justifying a capitalistic approach of accumulating money as a resource, however not as the final goal. Highlighting the success of free licenses in the development of the information era, which would be at a different stage would certain individuals not have followed the (hacker) money ethic. I think this is possibly the most important ideal. Whilst acknowledging that the hackers must live off something, therefore requiring some money, or that to develop certain technologies funds are needed, it highlights that making money should not be the goal of a hacker. In the capitalistic society we live in and the economical potential of technology, being enticed by the taste of money and riches can happen quickly, leading to more proprietary software and less digital freedom. Furthermore, in connection with (hacker) network ethic and freedom, keeping a non-economical approach is important also to guarantee freedom to others in the hacker community. Himanen himself reiterates the economical aspect in his definition of “caring”, in my opinion implying that caring is about the freedom of the information society.

              Although preserving and expanding freedom in the digital world is important, I do believe that certain set structures, meaning proprietary software, need to exist to avoid a digital anarchy. If we were to only live by these seven ideals, in the information society, the lack of rigid structures could pose a threat to non-IT experts or IT-experts that do not considers themselves part of the hackerdom.

Kommentare

Kommentar veröffentlichen

Beliebte Posts aus diesem Blog

WEEK11 Part1 Censorship: Who should censor?

       Censorship is a strongly debated topic, whilst some states used it to control the content their citizens can access, limiting their rights and freedoms, some institutions argue that their censorship protects its networks users. One example are libraries or educational institutions, especially schools censor certain websites such as gaming website, adult websites and possibly others. Some are blocked with the argument that they should not be accessed by children and for certain websites it’s the distraction that is a factor.      At our school initially YouTube was blocked which teachers very quickly recognized as a problem as our school was digitally proactive and incorporated online resources into everyday class. Multiple other websites were taken off the ban, however the school office was reluctant to remove the ban completely. Teachers and staff were provided with a separate internet connection so that they were not required to circumvent any security measures. However, whe
Mehr anzeigen

WEEK14 Neck-muscles from Typing - Paul Alexander

     In 1952 the six-year-old Paul Alexander becomes ill and soon is diagnosed with Polio. The chances are slim but he manages to survive, not without losing his mobility and physical freedom. Since then Alexander has been confined to the range of his “iron lung”. The iron long keeps his vital organs alive, but requires large amounts of energy and technical thus making a normal life extremely difficult. Alexander is immobilized from the neck down, however learned to use different tools with his mouth to draw, type or control other elements.      Alexander worked hard to learn to breathe without his iron lung. For the first three seconds he needed almost a year of practice, but he was tenacious and wanted to explore the yard, then the streets and after completing his studies he managed to appear in court as a lawyer for hours at end.      In 1967 Alexander succeeded in completing high school without ever attending class and went on to study law at the University of Texas (Austin). H
Mehr anzeigen

WEEK11 Part 2 Privacy: What if we know what they know?

     Another disputed topic is online privacy, should we have complete privacy? It is a very complicated discussion as the counter argument is strong. Complete privacy also ensures a high degree of anonymity therefore making it more difficult for law enforcement to identify criminals or other wrong doers. However, an individual with no intentions of criminal activity will feel wrongfully treated.      The NSA and other security agencies run security checks on specific words, phrases and activities on certain websites. If the words “bomb”, “how to build a weapon” etc. are searched the user will most probably be registered by their system. In such cases I would agree that an increased interest in such topics should be monitored as they could pose a certain threat, but as somebody that studies engineering and is sometimes merely interested in knowing how things work and the science behind certain technologies, I feel uncomfortable doing research on such topics. Furthermore, investigativ
Mehr anzeigen